Wednesday, August 11, 2010

Flappers Do Not Make Good Social Workers

“Brett looked at me. ‘I say,’ she said, ‘is Robert Cohn going on this trip?’

‘Yes. Why?’

‘Don’t you think it will be a bit rough on him?’

‘Why should it?’

‘Who do you think I went down to San Sebastian with….I rather thought it would be good for him.’

‘You might take up social service.’”

-The Sun Also Rises, p 89

To be honest, I am not particularly fond of Brett. It seems as though her actions are at least partially well-intended; they are merely misguided. Perhaps some men would enjoy spending a vacation with a beautiful woman and then having to endure interacting with this same woman—and her fiancé—several times after this. Frankly, though, I fail to find such an experience anything but rather awkward.

Considering Cohn’s emotional instability, Brett’s actions seem even more foolish. While others might be able to move on after being with Brett, Cohn will not. His past relationships have been too damaged and flawed for him to be able to simply move on. It appears that this possible strain between Robert and Brett—or maybe between Robert and Mike—will likely be the conflict that Hemingway has yet to include in this novel. Stay tuned to see if Hemingway actually includes a plot!

99 Bottles of Beer on the Wall...

“‘How about Vienna?’

‘Not so good, Jake. Not so good. It seemed better than it was.’

‘How do you mean?’ I was getting glasses and a siphon.

‘Tight, Jake. I was tight.’

‘That’s strange. Better have a drink.’

Bill rubbed his forehead. ‘Remarkable thing,’ he said. ‘Don’t know how it happened. Suddenly it happened.’

‘Last long?’

‘Four days, Jake. Lasted just four days.’”

-The Sun Also Rises, p 77

This passage reminded me of another observation that I have made while reading this novel: it seems that every character in this novel is either drunk or on their way to being drunk. Wherever two or three are gathered, there alcohol is in the midst of them. Now I understand that there is nothing wrong with adults drinking alcohol, and I am not condemning it. What I am noticing, however, is that each person consumes far more than what would be considered safe by today’s standards. Hemingway makes it seem that the bottles and glasses are emptying within minutes of each other. Considering that alcoholic drinks likely were much stronger in 1920s France than in 2010 America, where the alcohol content has likely been weakened for economic and health reasons, the fact that each person is consuming bottle after bottle is rather distressing, especially because none of them seem to have much control over their actions while “tight.”

Perhaps this was just the atmosphere du jour back then, but I have another theory, as well. It seems that Hemingway progresses the plot most when his characters are drunk. Perhaps Hemingway is simply using alcohol as a literary crutch.

Crazy Little Thing Called Love

“‘No, don’t come up,’ she said at the hotel. She had rung and the door was unlatched.

‘Really?’

‘No. Please.’

‘Good night, Brett,’ I said. ‘I’m sorry you feel rotten.’

‘Good night, Jake. Good night, darling. I won’t see you again.’ We kissed standing at the door. She pushed me away. We kissed again. ‘Oh, don’t!’ Brett said.

She turned quickly and went into the hotel.”

-The Sun Also Rises, p 71

I feel it is about time for me to vent my frustration over the rather annoyingly confusing relationship between Brett and Jake. It has been indicated that the two were once involved in some sort of romantic relationship. It has also been revealed that the two still love each other—or at least they claim to still love each other. Brett and Jake have also shared a total of four kisses within seventy-one pages. Despite these facts, Brett is engaged, and Jake does not seem to care.

Now, I can definitely understand former lovers remaining close friends with each other. I can also understand the statements that they still love each other. The kisses, however, contradict their current situation of separation. If Brett is engaged, and if Jake thinks Brett’s fiancé Mike is as great a person as he claims, then why do they insist on complicating these matters? They both have acknowledged the fact that nothing is going to happen between the two of them, so this romantic masochism seems utterly pointless.

Literary Waffling ("I Don't Like Robert Cohn," La Troisième Partie)

“Somehow I feel I have not shown Robert Cohn clearly. The reason is that until he fell in love with Brett, I never heard him make one remark that would, in any way, detach him from other people…Externally he had been formed at Princeton. Internally he had been molded [sic] by the two women who had trained him. He had a nice, boyish sort of cheerfulness that had never been trained out of him, and I probably have not brought it out. He loved to win at tennis. He probably loved to win as much as Lenglen, for instance. On the other hand, he was not angry at being beaten. When he fell in love with Brett his tennis game went all to pieces. People beat him who had never had a chance with him.”

-The Sun Also Rises, p 52

I find this paragraph slightly out of place. Here it seems that after spending fifty pages describing how stubborn and pathetic and exacerbating Robert Cohn is, Hemingway suddenly changes his mind and decided Cohn is not too of a fella after all. Personally, I just find it rather annoying. It would have served Hemingway much better to place this paragraph within the first five or ten pages of the novel, before the reader had already formed an image of Cohn. Frankly, I find it is much easier to change one’s opinion of a character from good to bad than from bad to good. It would have been much more effective to describe Cohn as a good person first, and then describe how Lady Brett affected his behavior. Instead, though, Hemingway shows Cohn’s behavior post-Brett exposure, then attempts to backtrack and prove in hindsight that Robert Cohn, despite fifty pages that say otherwise, is in fact a good person. I don’t believe it.

Hemingway's Cop Out ("I Don't Like Robert Cohn," La Deuxième Partie) (Stereotype)

“‘Oh, go to hell.’

He stood up from the table his face white, and stood there white and angry behind the little plates of hors d’œuvres. ‘Sit down,’ I said. Don’t be a fool.’

‘You’ve got to take that back.’

‘Oh, cut out the prep-school stuff.’

‘Take it back.’

‘Sure. Anything. I never heard of Brett Ashley. How’s that?’

‘No. Not that. About me going to hell.’

‘Oh, don’t go to hell,’ I said. ‘Stick around. We’re just starting lunch.’

Cohn smiled again and sat down. He seemed glad to sit down. What the hell would he have done if he hadn’t sat down? ‘You say such damned insulting things, Jake…. You’re really about the best friend I have, Jake.’

God help you, I thought.”

-The Sun Also Rises, p 47

In this passage, we see a glimpse of that “hard, Jewish, stubborn streak” (p 18) that Jake had already mentioned earlier. By writing Cohn like this, Hemingway places him within the stereotype that was held by mainstream America at the time concerning Jewish people. Cohn is depicted as extremely stubborn and rigid in ideals. He is also portrayed as increasingly short-tempered and testy. Yet Hemingway then proceeds to show that Cohn truly is not a fighter; in fact, it only takes a sarcastic apology from Jake to immediately put Cohn back at ease.

By giving Cohn such weak qualities and then repeatedly commenting on Cohn’s Judaism, Hemingway implies a stereotype that was prevalent at the time. Hemingway does nothing to refute the idea that Jews are stubbornly short-tempered, yet easy to please and, therefore, rather dim-witted. Considering how important Cohn seems to be to the plot, it almost seems like Hemingway is avoiding creating any sort of depth beside the expected depth of a Jew at the time.

Brett Is a Boy's Name (Indirect Characterization)

“Brett was damned good-looking. She wore a slipover jersey sweater and a tweed skirt, and her hair was brushed back like a boy’s. She started all that. She was built with curves like the hull of a racing yacht, and you missed none of it with that wool jersey….Dancing, I looked over Brett’s shoulder and saw Cohn, standing at the bar, still watching her. ‘You’ve made a new one there,’ I said to her.

‘Don’t talk about it. Poor chap. I never knew it till just now.’

‘Oh, well,’ I said. ‘I suppose you like to add them up.’

‘Don’t talk like a fool.’

‘You do.’

‘Oh, well. What if I do?’”

-The Sun Also Rises, p 29-30

This passage provides a pretty clear characterization of Lady Brett Ashley as what was commonly referred to as a “flapper” (thank you, Mrs. Helbing). Although Hemingway does not actually state that Brett is a flapper, it is evident that Brett fits the stereotypical mold. She wears her hair in a boyish style. Her clothes are much less modest than what was considered acceptable at the time. In addition, Hemingway reveals one of Brett’s chief traits: she flirts. A lot. By the tone of the dialogue between Jake and Brett, it seems likely that Brett has left a trail of broken hearts—or at least wounded prides—in her wake. Unfortunately, it appears that Cohn has entangled himself within her web. Considering what we know thus far of Cohn’s emotional instability, that can only spell trouble.

Monday, August 9, 2010

You Sad Little Man (Part One in the "I Don't Like Robert Cohn" Saga-Because I Feel This Will Not Be My Only Post on the Subject)

“‘Listen, Jake,’ he leaned forward on the bar. ‘Don’t you ever get the feeling that all your life is going by and you’re not taking advantage of it? Do you realize you’ve lived nearly half the time you have to live already?’

‘Yes, every once in a while.’

‘Do you know that in about thirty-five years more we’ll be dead?’

‘What the hell, Robert,’ I said. ‘What the hell.’”

-The Sun Also Rises, p 19

Well, Robert Cohn sounds like a cheerful character, doesn’t he? It seems that Cohn might be suffering some sort of midlife crisis. Then again, given his history, a midlife crisis is not too surprising. Hemingway does an excellent job of depicting Cohn as a rather pathetic creature. A victim of culture shock, Cohn becomes embittered and self-conscious. He marries the first girl that smiles at him. He then is shocked by his wife’s departure from him, though considering he was planning on doing the same, it seems as though the shock is not so much from the departure as from the idea that he was not his wife’s entire world. He promptly falls into the same rut with Frances.

Now, Cohn is suddenly beginning to realize that perhaps he does not have to attach himself to the first woman that shows him a bit of kindness. I am not stating this to summarize the plot; I am proving his patheity (thank you, chacha.com, for providing the noun form of “pathetic”). It is evident that Cohn is suffering from some degree of depression—or at least self-awareness—yet Hemingway’s rather despicable description of Cohn makes it rather difficult to show any amount of pity for him. It appears as though Hemingway wants the reader to feel pity for Cohn; frankly, I feel more disgust.